Permanent Rate Buydowns: Is Paying Discount Points Worth It In 2025?

When talking about mortgage rates, especially in 2025, everyone wants to know how to get a lower rate. One option you’ll here is to "buy down your rate." It's one of those mortgage strategies that sound like your ace-in-the-hole, but whether it actually makes sense depends on a few key factors. These include how long you plan to stay in the home, how much cash you want to spend upfront, and what the interest rate environment looks like.

This article will walk you through how discount points work, how to understand it’s financially responsible to do so by calculating your break-even period, and if buying down your rate is a wise investment or an unnecessary expense in today’s rapidly changing mortgage market.

What Are Discount Points?

Discount points, sometimes just called points, are essentially prepaid interest. You pay a fee upfront at closing to secure a lower interest rate on your mortgage. One point equals 1% of your total loan amount. Each point typically lowers your rate by about 0.25%, though the exact amount can vary depending on the market and your lender's pricing structure.

Let’s say you’re taking out a $400,000 loan. One discount point would cost you $4,000. In return, your rate might drop from 7.00% to 6.75%. If you buy three points for $12,000, your rate might go down to 6.25%. This upfront investment only makes sense if you stick around long enough to enjoy the savings.

To help visualize the impact of buying points, take a look at the comparison below:

In both scenarios, it takes 5 years to break even. After that, the monthly savings begin to outpace the upfront cost. At that point, the buydown becomes a net financial gain. But if you sell or refinance before hitting that breakeven point, you’ll lose money.

Is Buying Down Your Rate Worth It?

The logic behind a permanent rate buydown is sound. You exchange a lump sum today for smaller monthly payments over time. That smaller monthly obligation can improve your debt-to-income ratio. It may also help you qualify for a larger loan. Most importantly, it can lead to long-term interest savings.

However, this is not a one-size-fits-all decision. The downsides are just as real. Discount points require a sizable chunk of cash at closing. That’s money many homebuyers would rather use for a higher down payment, renovations, or simply keeping reserves in the bank. More importantly, the risk lies in your timeline. If you refinance or sell your home before you reach that breakeven point, the savings never materialize and the cost becomes a sunk expense.

Sometimes, working with a mortgage broker can be the edge you need to get a lower rate without having to pay points.

Interest Rates in 2025 and Why Your Timeline Matters

As of June 2025, mortgage rates are hovering near 6.9%, according to Freddie Mac. This is historically high compared to the ultra-low rates we saw from 2020 through early 2022. However, there's a growing consensus among economists that rates may start to come down. The Federal Reserve has paused rate hikes, inflation is coming down, and many analysts, including those quoted in Forbes, expect one or more Fed cuts by the end of the year.

Here’s the catch. If rates do fall, and you're like many borrowers who plan to refinance as soon as that happens, then paying for a buydown now could be a waste of money. That $4,000 to $12,000 you spent on points may only yield a few months of benefit before you replace the loan with a new one, meaning you threw a lot of money away.

This is why understanding your likely timeline is so important. Are you planning to stay put for the long haul? Or are you eyeing a refinance as soon as market conditions improve? These questions should drive your decision-making process.

A buyer who knows they’ll be in the home for more than 10 years with no plans to refinance could absolutely benefit from a buydown. But that’s not the average borrower in today’s market. Most buyers in 2025 are entering with the full expectation that they’ll refinance within 12 to 24 months.

If you’re reasonably confident that rates will fall and you’ll be refinancing soon, it makes little sense to buy points. You’ll never hit your breakeven mark. If you’re planning to sell within that same time frame, the argument against paying points becomes even stronger.

If we look back at 2024, we saw rates go from around 7.125% to 5.875% between April and September. Many of our borrowers who just purchased in 2023 and early 2024 took advantage of the drop to refinance. While rates crept back up to the 7% range shortly after and have remained there since, the borrowers that took advantage of the opportunity saved thousands on interest and they may not have done it if they spent money to needlessly buy down their rate.

Instead of asking whether you can afford to buy down the rate, you should be asking whether you’re likely to keep this loan long enough for it to pay off. That’s the real heart of the decision.

Temporary Buydowns: A More Flexible Option in 2025

A temporary buydown offers a more adaptable alternative to permanent points. Rather than lowering your rate for the full life of the loan, it gives you a reduced rate for the first one to three years. This is done using escrowed funds applied to your monthly payment.

Take the 2-1 buydown for example. If your final rate is 7.00%, you would pay 5.00% in Year 1, 6.00% in Year 2, and 7.00% from Year 3 onward. The cost to do this is typically funded by the seller or lender as part of a closing credit. That means it usually does not come out of your pocket.

If you refinance during the buydown period, any unused portion of the escrowed funds is either refunded or applied to your payoff. That gives you flexibility that permanent points simply do not offer.

This is why many buyers in today’s market are leaning toward temporary buydowns. They offer immediate payment relief without locking up thousands in cash. Even more important, they align with current expectations that rates will likely be lower in the near future.

To dive deeper into how they work, check out our full guide here: Temporary Buydowns Explained

Final Take: Make Decisions Based on Strategy, Not Just the Rate

Buying down your mortgage rate can be a smart play, but it can also be a waste of money. To make sure it’s a smart play you need to have a strong understanding of your timing and long-term financial plans. In today’s high-rate environment, the odds are stacked against most permanent buydowns being worth it. Unless you’re absolutely sure you’re keeping your loan for at least 5 years, the better move might be to save your cash.

Temporary buydowns provide a more balanced alternative. They give you lower payments now and the flexibility to refinance later, without losing money you may never recover.

If you want a real-world analysis of your options, talk to a lender who understands how to break down the numbers and build a strategy around your specific goals. At LendFriend Mortgage, we help clients compare scenarios every day. We'll tell you exactly when a buydown makes sense and when it's better to keep that cash in your pocket.

 Give us a call at 512.881.5099 or get in touch with me by completing this quick form, and I'll be in touch as soon as possible.